An Impossible DreamDiane Ravitch,
contributed an op-ed piece today, stating Congressional mandates for school reform, Dubya's No Child Left Behind legislation, hasn't worked, won't work, and is poorly conceived and designed.
Ravitch maintains that the appropriate federal role in school reform is to continue to disseminate measurement data, which the states will use to help improve student achievement. The current role the feds take isn't working, Ravitch says, because each state has its own measurement system, which is different from state-to-state. Additionally, Ravitch addresses the elephant in the room: no society has ever achieved 100% proficiency in math and reading. Ever.
Ravitch is correct about NCLB's goal of universal proficiency; if you have an unrealistic goal, how does one go about achieving it? Through snow jobs, utilizing a lot of statistics. (Remember the idiom: there are lies, damn lies, and statistics.)
Ruben Navarrette, on the other hand, claims it is the adults (administrators, lawmakers, teachers unions, etc.) who are s
crewing-up school reform. Navarrette's opinions are just that, however. He rarely, if at all, produces any empirical, peer reviewed, data to suggest NCLB, of which he is a true believer, to be the silver bullet to the nation's education woes.
There is no doubt we need education reform in this country, one that includes accountability and measurement. Navarrette, however, opines that teachers, because of job security and personal interest, (and he doesn't use any modifications: all teachers) don't want school reform.
I, as a teacher, want school reform. I want accountability. I want measurement. I want realistic goals, too. Education, like everything on this earth, is not immune to the forces of society. NCLB (as is) states that all children will succeed in reading and math all the time. That is not realistic. However, no one is willing to discuss which student populations will not get the resources to become proficient.
Labels: Diane Ravitch, education, education reform, NCLB, Ruben Navarrette